Debt-stricken families with new homes, cars and plasma televisions in Sydney’s sprawling housing estates are relying on charity handouts to buy food.
Welfare agencies report a worrying increase in the number of middle-income families with big mortgages seeking help to pay grocery, electricity and gas bills.
Dubbed the “pay-later poor” by St Vincent de Paul, they live in homes boasting cable television and the latest electrical goods and use credit cards to meet basic living costs.
Many of the families live in so-called McMansions.
Rising interest rates and petrol prices have hit them hard, with the latest figures showing soaring personal debt levels and bankruptcies.
With rates tipped to rise again next month, the blame game has begun, with the State Government accusing Federal Treasurer Peter Costello of economic mismanagement.
St Vincent de Paul Society chief executive officer John Picot said families were seeking cash and vouchers to buy food and clothing, and pay electricity and water bills and other debts.
He blamed a “want-it-all” attitude for the trend.
Those who took up “buy now, pay later” offers and store credit cards often found themselves in difficulty when the interest-free periods ran out, a member of the family fell ill or one of the family’s breadwinners lost a job.
“I call them the pay-nothing-now poor – couples who have wanted everything now,” he said.
“Retailers have created this new breed of poor – people who have over-extended themselves to buy a new home and then signed up to all these contracts to get the furniture, the television and cable.
“Suddenly there is a quarter per cent rise in interest rates and or a hike in petrol prices and of course, it’s a disaster.
“We never heard of borrowing money from the bank to pay for wine or to get our hair done in the 1970s – that would have been an absolute nonsense – but that’s what we are doing now through all these credit cards.
“I’m not just blaming the banks or retailers – there has to be some personal responsibility taken.”
Mission Australia and the Salvation Army have also reported an increase in the number of homeowners seeking charity handouts.
Mr Picot said while the charity refused to cover mortgage repayments, it had helped out with food and electricity vouchers.
Families in financial difficulties were also referred to a budget counsellor on how to manage their debt.
“We say, you have to make some decisions or choices, such as maybe looking at winding up the cable TV contract,” Mr Picot said.
“Our focus is always on the society’s most disadvantaged but we will always help in a crisis. We will always make sure there is food on the table.”
Figures compiled by St Vincent de Paul for The Sunday Telegraph show the number of welfare recipients has soared in the past five years.
Case-workers visited 235,718 homes last year – an increase of over 29,000 compared with five years ago.
In the year to June, more than $11.5 million worth of assistance was given – up from $8 million five years ago.
While singles and sole parents were the major recipients, couples with a child were also high on the list.
More than $2.3 million was handed out so families could buy food.
Almost $2.5 million worth of vouchers were issued to pay electricity bills. Another $150,000 worth of vouchers paid for water.
An Illawarra case-worker said some families appeared on the surface to be well-off with “a large house and plasma TV” but had sought help because they could not pay the bills.
Mission Australia reported an estimated 25 per cent increase in cases of homeowners asking for assistance for the first time.
The charity’s State manager of financial counselling services, Barbara Jones, said the rise indicated an alarming trend and was likely due to the increased cost of living.
“My financial counsellors have reported a significant increase in cases where both partners are working but are still struggling to make ends meet, without enough money for food and electricity,” she said.
“The rise in petrol prices and interest rates make it incredibly difficult to afford things like food.
“Five years ago, you would be lucky to see 10 per cent of these cases – now it’s up to 35 per cent.”
New figures from the Insolvency and Trustee Service Australia showed bankruptcies in NSW increased 18 per cent in the past year.
Personal debt accounted for 88 per cent of the bankruptcies.
The ING Direct-Melbourne Institute Household Saving & Investment Report showed the latest interest rate rise had had the greatest impact on NSW households.
Over one-third of NSW residents were worried about the effects of the rise, it said.
Six per cent of NSW households were running into debt to meet daily expenses – up from four per cent in the previous quarter.
NSW Treasurer Michael Costa blamed rate rises for people falling harder into debt.
“Interest rate rises are hurting NSW families,” he said.
“As I said at the time, the Federal Budget added to the inflationary pressures that saw the Reserve Bank raising interest rates for the seventh successive time in August.
“Prior to the May interest rate rise, the property sector was showing signs of improving demand, with increased housing finance approvals, low vacancy rates, and rising rents all pointing towards a recovery.”
poor
This couple found themselves in difficult times when they had their baby. / The Daily Telegraph
Also in NSW/ACT
* New war over HSC
* Maroubra: Beach bashings over territory
* Sanctions: Korea banned from our ports
* Iemma tackles Ashes thugs
* NRL shame: Mascot caught with child porn
* On the rise: Breast cancer survival boost
* Cop that: Academy police unfit to teach
* Drought: Reviewing relief for farmers
* Downer: PNG links reviewed over Moti
* Ohh ah, catwalk star
* Jolie pans our refugee record
* Gale stands strong in surf
* Just the job: Hospitality courses boom
Font size: + –
Send this article: Print Email
Have Your Say
Latest Comments:
I think it is very easy to take the moral high ground on this topic. How many of you have jobs that rely on many of these families signing up to buy now – pay later deals, or marketing an image that is essentially unsustainable for the majority of Australians households. How many of you are geting rich by facillitating others to live beyond their means……?
Posted by: Shanon Cuskelly of North Sydney 4:12pm October 15, 2006
No, these people should not be given hand-outs because they suffer from their own greed. They should remember that for every dollar in income, 99c spent results in happiness; $1.01 spent, results in misery. How can anyone think this is the fault of the Government?
Posted by: may waddington of Gunnedah 3:31pm October 15, 2006
I wonder if these people were educated in the Public Education System?
Posted by: Jolanda Challita of Miranda 3:25pm October 15, 2006
No sympathy here either….people need to be responsible for their own debt in these situations. Perhaps basic life skills courses need to be made compulsory in schools such as budgeting, cost of borrowing etc. While charities do a great job, they should not be rorted by preventable situations.
Posted by: Narelle Gibson of 3:24pm October 15, 2006
Rebecca of Grose vale, YOUR RIGHT ON IT…. YOU ROCK!!! Thankyou BigKev
Posted by: BIGKEV of SYD 3:06pm October 15, 2006
We now live in a country were you don’t have to take responsibility for your own actions, as there is always a caring hard working person out there who will pick up your slack. If you cannot afford to pay for food and electricity and you have a new car or a plasma TV, go find mirror and take a good hard look at yourself and stop being a burden to the charitable organizations that have real work to do.
Posted by: Shaun Davies of 2:33pm October 15, 2006
Todays story is a eye opener to all the people of Australia. If you cant afford it you cant have it .dont try to live above your living standards SHAME SHAME SHAME
Posted by: debbie andriske of 2:11pm October 15, 2006
These people are crying poor because they have over committed themselves. I believe that charities are for the homeless and the poor that are in geniune need. Maybe these people should sell off their assets to overcome their debts. Maybe they should try living in the streets to really see what poor is, it was their greed that put them into debt. We should leave charities for the geniune that really are poor.
Posted by: Mary of NSW 1:23pm October 15, 2006
I do not have a plasma TV or cable TV. I do not owe any debt for such luxuries either. I have never needed welfare or any government hand-outs. Every year for the past 20 years, I have donated money to welfare agencies to help the poor at Christmas time. Now that I know some of the money I donated are feeding people who have plasma TV and cable TV, I will stop donating money. I will use the money to buy a plasma TV for myself with cash.
Posted by: Voter of 12:47pm October 15, 2006
These mindless people disgust me. Welfare agencies shold stop providing assistance to these stupid and greedy people. Their greed and stupidity got them into this situation! They must take responsibility for their own actions and not cry on the shoulders of Welfare agencies.
Posted by: Sylvie Welsh of 12:40pm October 15, 2006
The above link will lead to a fascinating discussion of hidden issues. At the time of this poasting there were more than 40 comments on this item in the Sidney newspaper.
